LVHunter

Member
Joined
Jun 15, 2012
Messages
6
Reaction score
5
This is more for information for other apprentice elk hunters than anything. My son drew a Bishop 2 Apprentice Elk Cow Tag. I was lucky enough to draw an X9A tag and was not able to hunt the area until the last week of the season. My plan was to deer hunt with a friend for three days and then have a another friend bring my son up Thursday night after school. My son plays high school football and just happened to have a "bye" on the Friday before the elk opener.

So, my friend and I went hunting in X9A at the beginning of last week and hunted three days. We saw about 100 plus does and yearlings, but no legal bucks. We did camp next to a family from Thousand Oaks, who had camped and hunted for two weeks. In total, they shot two forkies and one nice 3x3.

On Thursday, we drove my trailer down and camped near Bishop. I called the DFG Office in Bishop (as instructed in the Big Game regs booklet) to see if there would be a meeting for the apprentice hunters and to see if they were going to maybe share info as to where the herds have been frequenting, since it is a large area. I finally got in touch with a female that stated, "Oh, I haven't been in that area in awhile, so I can't help you." I'm sure a warden would have helped, but I was not going to ask for any favors, because we know those guys are spread thin. I still had confidence since I had two days to scout the area.

My friend and I scouted for elk Thursday and after 4 hours of beating my Suburban up on jeep trails, we spotted a bull and a few cows. It was very apparent after two days of watching this small group, that they have been chased and shot at several times. A local deer hunter told us he had been deer hunting in the hills to the west of 395 (outside our elk boundaries) and said he saw a big herd of elk, which he stated he had never seen them up that high before.

On Saturday, my son and I spotted the small group about a mile away at about 7:15 in the morning. The wind was not right so we started making a large 3/4 mile stalk on foot around the south side of the elk. After 1 1/2 hours of walking and jumping over a barbed wire fence, I started to turn west around the back of the group. About 15 minutes later, I looked up and saw the antlers of the bull. They had moved south about a half a mile! AND, of course, as luck would have it, the wind shifted about 10 degrees right towards the elk. My guess is that they were about 300 yards away.

I told my son that this was going to be the closest shot because they are going to run. He wrapped his arm in the rifle sling and set the stock of his rifle on the shooting stick. Since they had not run, but were acting real nervous and was ready to run I told him he would have to take the next best shot he can at a cow. He took a shot and I didn't see any flinch or blood coming from any of the cows as they trotted and then walked out of the area. When they got out at about 700 yards they took off again at a full gallop. We checked for blood in the area where the cow was standing, but nothing. We followed their tracks south for 2 1/2 miles and never found any blood. I called my two friends to pick us up at the next road, which was 3 miles away from my truck, where we started.

It was a bummer that my son missed, but I didn't plan on him having to take that long of a shot. I would have told him to hold off if I knew there was another herd that we could go after as a back up. I just wanted to share this because I have heard statements in the forums how DFG has meetings before the hunts for the apprentice hunters, some state it's a culling hunt they (DFG) wants you to be successful, they will drive you out there and point out where the herds are for the young hunters. I don't know how it has been for apprentice hunters in the past, but none of that was the case for me and my son. If you get picked for an elk hunt in California and don't have a week to scout, I highly suggest a licensed guide who can make your hunt more complete, especially for our young hunters.

The important thing is my son and I had a blast and my son experienced the down side of hunting, which is missing a shot. I feel more to blame since I told him to take the shot. He has taken two wild pigs before a 100 yard shot and a 200 yard shot. I do believe more is learned through failure sometimes, especially in hunting. I know it has for me as a bowhunter. You learn something everytime you hunt. Since we both had X9A tags we went deer hunting Saturday afternoon and Sunday morning. We were up northwest of Bishop up in the hills, looking over the world. Unfortunately, he had to get back to school for Monday which cut our hunting trip short. Maybe next time. He has a football game this week so unsure if we are going back to Bishop this weekend for another try at the elk.
 

DMC

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 5, 2004
Messages
469
Reaction score
1
That is to bad for your boy.

My wife has a bull tag for that unit and I scouted it for only 2 days and saw exactly 2 bulls no cows. I thought right then wow this is going to be a lot harder than I thought. Sounds like the elk just are not in the area. Only time will tell. 3bull tags and 3 cow tags things should be interesting.
 

Nickman

Active member
Joined
Apr 16, 2006
Messages
25
Reaction score
7
Wrong.......all the way around.

There are between 60 and 80 elk in the Bishop zone. There have only been about 5 rifle hunters there this year, so the elk are not all that spooky......unless you chase them.

YOU failed to properly plan and scout for YOUR son's hunt. Had YOU taken the time, YOU would have found several locals, guides, and ranchers, who would have helped YOUR SON take his cow.....no charge!

YOU elected to deer hunt instead of properly scouting for YOUR SON's hunt and then want to blame DFG for not holding your hand and showing YOUR SON some animals......you even trashed an office staffer for not finding the herds.....Seriously?

Then, and maybe worst of all, YOU decide to go deer hunting instead of helping YOUR SON take his cow......WTF?

The failure of this hunt is all on YOU and YOUR priorities.

This is a fairly simple hunt with a high success rate, but YOU have to take the time to make it work right. YOU failed to do that.


As for the guy whose wife has the bull tag. You will have to quit driving around, find a high spot and glass up your bull. This ain't a zoo or a "high fence" operation. You can't chase these animals and once they spot you.......it's over.
 

baco

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 4, 2009
Messages
828
Reaction score
7
Wrong.......all the way around.

There are between 60 and 80 elk in the Bishop zone. There have only been about 5 rifle hunters there this year, so the elk are not all that spooky......unless you chase them.

YOU failed to properly plan and scout for YOUR son's hunt. Had YOU taken the time, YOU would have found several locals, guides, and ranchers, who would have helped YOUR SON take his cow.....no charge!

YOU elected to deer hunt instead of properly scouting for YOUR SON's hunt and then want to blame DFG for not holding your hand and showing YOUR SON some animals......you even trashed an office staffer for not finding the herds.....Seriously?

Then, and maybe worst of all, YOU decide to go deer hunting instead of helping YOUR SON take his cow......WTF?

The failure of this hunt is all on YOU and YOUR priorities.

This is a fairly simple hunt with a high success rate, but YOU have to take the time to make it work right. YOU failed to do that.


As for the guy whose wife has the bull tag. You will have to quit driving around, find a high spot and glass up your bull. This ain't a zoo or a "high fence" operation. You can't chase these animals and once they spot you.......it's over.


May come off as a little harsh but you are dead right
 

Live2hunt

Forever Hunting
Joined
Sep 24, 2002
Messages
2,289
Reaction score
20
You did the scouting and located the elk. Your son got a shot and missed. What more could you ask for in just a one day hunt?
 

DMC

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 5, 2004
Messages
469
Reaction score
1
As for the guy whose wife has the bull tag. You will have to quit driving around, find a high spot and glass up your bull. This ain't a zoo or a "high fence" operation. You can't chase these animals and once they spot you.......it's over.

Never thought it was a High Fence or a Zoo. Only had 2 days to scout. First thing I learned was hey this is pretty darn flat. Then talked to a rancher who was very nice and gave me his number and said if we shot one in his area to call him and he would help get the truck as close as possible. Then made a decision that hey If I spot one here I have to know how to even get close better learn what roads go were. Saw areas that I thought looked good to hold elk but marked them to walk in durring the hunt. Talked to a local sporting goods store and asked straight out hey is there any roads or areas that I can get some elevation to glass from. They were really helpful. I thought my scouting trip was a success but I was a bit suprised I did not see more elk. Then I see a post about having a hard time finding elk in the area. It really doesn't matter because we are going and will give it our all when we get there. Its hunting and who knows what will happen. If ya got any suggestions for the area I am all ears
 

DAWG

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 11, 2002
Messages
769
Reaction score
14
Regardless.... I really do hope to see LVHunter post up a pic of his son with a cow elk from this weekend.
 

LVHunter

Member
Joined
Jun 15, 2012
Messages
6
Reaction score
5
Bishop 2 Apprentice Elk Hunt

Wrong.......all the way around.

There are between 60 and 80 elk in the Bishop zone. There have only been about 5 rifle hunters there this year, so the elk are not all that spooky......unless you chase them.

YOU failed to properly plan and scout for YOUR son's hunt. Had YOU taken the time, YOU would have found several locals, guides, and ranchers, who would have helped YOUR SON take his cow.....no charge!

YOU elected to deer hunt instead of properly scouting for YOUR SON's hunt and then want to blame DFG for not holding your hand and showing YOUR SON some animals......you even trashed an office staffer for not finding the herds.....Seriously?

Then, and maybe worst of all, YOU decide to go deer hunting instead of helping YOUR SON take his cow......WTF?

The failure of this hunt is all on YOU and YOUR priorities.

This is a fairly simple hunt with a high success rate, but YOU have to take the time to make it work right. YOU failed to do that.


As for the guy whose wife has the bull tag. You will have to quit driving around, find a high spot and glass up your bull. This ain't a zoo or a "high fence" operation. You can't chase these animals and once they spot you.......it's over.

"Nickman" you are right that I could have scouted a few days more, absolutely. I regret that now. Although I was with a buddy who had an X9A tag also so WE decided to deer hunt a few days. At the beginning of my story I put in quotes "This is more for information for other apprentice elk hunters than anything" That's because I undersestimated the size of this area. This story was not a complaint of anything, so if anyone feels that way, I apologize. I have only driven through there and looked at maps of the area. If I knew how vast this area was with the poor roads I would have opted for a guide. Unfortunately, with my job I could not take off anymore weekends. So, I shared my story to give other hunters a "heads up" that this area is no "walk in the park."

Addressing your remark about "there have only been 5 rifle hunters there this year, so the elk are not all that spooky....unless you chase them." That goes against what I personally observed and what many of the locals stated to me in Bishop. I did talk to many people in town from sporting goods stores to cafes. One person's exact words were, "They've been bowhunted, blackpowder hunted and now rifle, those guys (elk) are really on edge right now."

One more thing, if you think I was "trashing" a DFG office staffer you are just plain mistaken. I was stating facts in my story. If you take that as "trashing" you need to cut back on the caffeine. The Big Game Regs state to call the DFG biologist in Bishop and they give you a number, which I called and left a message. The BIOLOGIST called me back while I was out scouting. I asked her several questions about a pre-hunt meeting, if she is familiar with their habits, etc. She had no answer for me so I was pretty perplexed why we need to call them. I guess the best question I could have asked her was why does it say to call the biologist, I forgot to ask that. I stated facts and did not sensationalize anything like some do. Remember this is info for other hunters, the only reason I wrote in this forum. I work on a regular basis with DFG personnel, especially Game Wardens, I have the outmost respect for them.

I hope I have clarified a few things for everyone. I'll repeat what I said in my original story that got overlooked by "Nickman." "If you don't have a week to scout for these elk, I highly suggest a licensed guide who can make your hunt more complete, especially for our young hunters." I learned the hard way.
 

LVHunter

Member
Joined
Jun 15, 2012
Messages
6
Reaction score
5
Regardless.... I really do hope to see LVHunter post up a pic of his son with a cow elk from this weekend.

"Dawg" We weren't able to go back out. My son twisted his ankle at his Friday night football game and is now on crutches. Thanks anyway for the good wishes!
 

Latest Posts

QRCode

QR Code
Top Bottom