Speckmisser
Well-known member
- Joined
- Mar 12, 2001
- Messages
- 12,900
- Reaction score
- 27
This topic is an extension of FeelinBirdy's Homework for Hog Hunting thread.
It came about following this from Bill W.
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE </div>
I'm not looking to start anything here, but I guess it's time for my perennial rant about shooting too far at game.
I have never heard a convincing argument to support the need to shoot 400+ yards at any wild game, but especially not at something as resilient as a wild hog. A good shot with a good round will certainly kill the animal... often cleanly. But what do you do when you don't kill cleanly? Take another look at this snip from hoghunter714's post I'm Back...
Take special note of the last line in parentheses.
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE </div>
If it weren't for the dogs, they would never have recovered that sow. And remember that dogs aren't allowed at Tejon.
Now I'll be the first to admit that a situation like that can happen at 10 feet with the same consequences, but the odds of it happening at 400 yards are multiplied by a huge factor. Add in the fact that, in the case quoted above he shot at running pigs, and your likelihood of a clean hit and kill is practically nil.
But you take the shot anyway, and you hear the smack of bullet hitting pig. He squeals like hell and takes off over the ridgetop. Now what?
How far can you hike in a straight line in pig country? 400 yards is 120 feet short of a quarter of a mile. In a quarter of a mile of pig country, that usually entails up and down canyons and through the chapparal. At the end of that quarter mile hike, you have to locate the spot where the pig was standing when you shot in order to start trailing. Can you do that?
Now here's where it gets really interesting. Pigs don't generally leave a very good blood trail. If they're bleeding hard enough to leave a trail, they didn't go far... so there's a positive note. But due to the heavy layer of fat most of them carry, a normal bullet wound will barely leak externally. Also, consider that you may or may not get a through and through shot. This means there won't be an exit wound, which is usually the best source of tracking blood since it's usually much larger than the entry.
Anecdotal experience... I shot my Tejon hog last year at less than 25 yards with a 30-06, shooting a 168gr ballistic tip. The bullet shattered the onside shoulder, literally liquified the heart and one lung and lodged on the offside under the skin. There were a couple of drops of blood where I hit the hog, and a few drops where he fell, about 40 yards downhill. There was NO BLOOD over that 40 yard trail. And by the way, even with that damage he was still trying to get up when I got to him and put a .44 mag into his brain.
But let's just say that, by some miracle (or by having another hunter spot for you), you found where the animal was standing, and you actually find some blood. Now for complication #3.
Anybody want to describe typical pig country? While the pigs may come out to some fairly open areas to feed or water, you can bet there's a patch of the thickest, nastiest stuff known to man nearby for a quick escape. If a wounded pig hits that stuff, your odds of recovery are slimming to none real fast. The stuff is impossible to walk through upright, and even if you do bulldoze through, you won't be able to see the ground while you're doing it. You will have to crawl, at best, just to try to follow the blood spoor.
Add to this the fact that you're going in after a wounded pig. A small boar or sow isn't necessarily a big deal, but if you happened to take that shot at a big pig, you're going into enemy territory with a hostile and well-armed opponent. Ask any houndsman what happens to the dogs if they get too close to a bayed boar. The advantage you had at a distance with that high-powered rifle is all gone now. This is where a backup handgun may come in handy, although if you should get charged in that thick stuff, your best bet is to beat a retreat to where YOU have the advantage again.
But getting charged is the least of my concerns, and should only be a back-of-the-mind thing for you too. Sure it happens, and it can get ugly... but it doesn't happen as much as some folks would have you think.
What's more important is that now you have a wounded animal lost in the chapparal. Odds of recovery are decreasing by the moment, especially if it's dark or getting that way. You can beat the bushes, go get some help, and maybe you'll find the pig. Or not. Even the most dedicated and ethical hunter sometimes has to throw in the towel and admit that they crippled and lost an animal.
But that's not what you're out there for, is it?
So all this is to say, in spite of your rifle's capabilities, avoid those super-long shots. If it's over 200 yards, you should be able to get closer. If you can't, then the animal wins. That's part of the sport. Find another animal and start over. It'll only improve your skills as a big game hunter to learn to do those "impossible" stalks. Remember, people bowhunt these animals too, so you can be sure that it's possible to get close with a little skill (and sometimes a little luck).
Pigs are especially easy to stalk, as long as you can play the wind and move relatively quietly. If they're not alert, they make lots of noise themselves, and they can't see worth a hoot. With the wind in your face, you should have no problem finding a way to within 100 yards for a comfortable, easy shot (usually a lot closer, if you want). Part of being ethical means doing everything possible to ensure a good shot, clean kill, and recovery.
Think about this, too... if the terrain is so bad that you can't close to a reasonable range for the shot, what is it going to mean for your recovery effort, especially if the pig runs off?
As I mentioned before, there's a lot more to being a successful hunter than just picking a good gun and being a good shot. Hunting is NOT target shooting. You have to think about what happens before AND after the shot. You have to plan for worst-case scenarios, and be prepared to follow through on that plan. If you're not thus prepared, then you shouldn't be there. Period.
It came about following this from Bill W.
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE </div>
That 30-06 with 165 grain bullets is 400 yard medicine or better on a pig if you practice and can accurately estimate yardage.[/b]
I'm not looking to start anything here, but I guess it's time for my perennial rant about shooting too far at game.
I have never heard a convincing argument to support the need to shoot 400+ yards at any wild game, but especially not at something as resilient as a wild hog. A good shot with a good round will certainly kill the animal... often cleanly. But what do you do when you don't kill cleanly? Take another look at this snip from hoghunter714's post I'm Back...
Take special note of the last line in parentheses.
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE </div>
Just as the hogs are to the top of the hill I can see them now. Jeff reloads his Ruger #1 and "KA BOOM" he hits a big sow on the rear left leg breaking her leg. Now she toped the hill and is out of site. Kek lets one of his dogs go cause she is wounded now. Daylight is almost gone and we have to move fast. We start hiking and the dog is LONG GONE. We stop and we hear barking off to the distance and know the dog has the pig at bay. After another 600 yard hike we finally reach the pig and dog (This pig traveled 600 yards with a broken rear leg...Amazing).[/b]
If it weren't for the dogs, they would never have recovered that sow. And remember that dogs aren't allowed at Tejon.
Now I'll be the first to admit that a situation like that can happen at 10 feet with the same consequences, but the odds of it happening at 400 yards are multiplied by a huge factor. Add in the fact that, in the case quoted above he shot at running pigs, and your likelihood of a clean hit and kill is practically nil.
But you take the shot anyway, and you hear the smack of bullet hitting pig. He squeals like hell and takes off over the ridgetop. Now what?
How far can you hike in a straight line in pig country? 400 yards is 120 feet short of a quarter of a mile. In a quarter of a mile of pig country, that usually entails up and down canyons and through the chapparal. At the end of that quarter mile hike, you have to locate the spot where the pig was standing when you shot in order to start trailing. Can you do that?
Now here's where it gets really interesting. Pigs don't generally leave a very good blood trail. If they're bleeding hard enough to leave a trail, they didn't go far... so there's a positive note. But due to the heavy layer of fat most of them carry, a normal bullet wound will barely leak externally. Also, consider that you may or may not get a through and through shot. This means there won't be an exit wound, which is usually the best source of tracking blood since it's usually much larger than the entry.
Anecdotal experience... I shot my Tejon hog last year at less than 25 yards with a 30-06, shooting a 168gr ballistic tip. The bullet shattered the onside shoulder, literally liquified the heart and one lung and lodged on the offside under the skin. There were a couple of drops of blood where I hit the hog, and a few drops where he fell, about 40 yards downhill. There was NO BLOOD over that 40 yard trail. And by the way, even with that damage he was still trying to get up when I got to him and put a .44 mag into his brain.
But let's just say that, by some miracle (or by having another hunter spot for you), you found where the animal was standing, and you actually find some blood. Now for complication #3.
Anybody want to describe typical pig country? While the pigs may come out to some fairly open areas to feed or water, you can bet there's a patch of the thickest, nastiest stuff known to man nearby for a quick escape. If a wounded pig hits that stuff, your odds of recovery are slimming to none real fast. The stuff is impossible to walk through upright, and even if you do bulldoze through, you won't be able to see the ground while you're doing it. You will have to crawl, at best, just to try to follow the blood spoor.
Add to this the fact that you're going in after a wounded pig. A small boar or sow isn't necessarily a big deal, but if you happened to take that shot at a big pig, you're going into enemy territory with a hostile and well-armed opponent. Ask any houndsman what happens to the dogs if they get too close to a bayed boar. The advantage you had at a distance with that high-powered rifle is all gone now. This is where a backup handgun may come in handy, although if you should get charged in that thick stuff, your best bet is to beat a retreat to where YOU have the advantage again.
But getting charged is the least of my concerns, and should only be a back-of-the-mind thing for you too. Sure it happens, and it can get ugly... but it doesn't happen as much as some folks would have you think.
What's more important is that now you have a wounded animal lost in the chapparal. Odds of recovery are decreasing by the moment, especially if it's dark or getting that way. You can beat the bushes, go get some help, and maybe you'll find the pig. Or not. Even the most dedicated and ethical hunter sometimes has to throw in the towel and admit that they crippled and lost an animal.
But that's not what you're out there for, is it?
So all this is to say, in spite of your rifle's capabilities, avoid those super-long shots. If it's over 200 yards, you should be able to get closer. If you can't, then the animal wins. That's part of the sport. Find another animal and start over. It'll only improve your skills as a big game hunter to learn to do those "impossible" stalks. Remember, people bowhunt these animals too, so you can be sure that it's possible to get close with a little skill (and sometimes a little luck).
Pigs are especially easy to stalk, as long as you can play the wind and move relatively quietly. If they're not alert, they make lots of noise themselves, and they can't see worth a hoot. With the wind in your face, you should have no problem finding a way to within 100 yards for a comfortable, easy shot (usually a lot closer, if you want). Part of being ethical means doing everything possible to ensure a good shot, clean kill, and recovery.
Think about this, too... if the terrain is so bad that you can't close to a reasonable range for the shot, what is it going to mean for your recovery effort, especially if the pig runs off?
As I mentioned before, there's a lot more to being a successful hunter than just picking a good gun and being a good shot. Hunting is NOT target shooting. You have to think about what happens before AND after the shot. You have to plan for worst-case scenarios, and be prepared to follow through on that plan. If you're not thus prepared, then you shouldn't be there. Period.