StringShooter

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 23, 2001
Messages
1,098
Reaction score
1
When I took my 20 yard broadside shot, the last thing that I amagined was that I would not recover the deer.

I practice a lot. I spend the time to be assured that the animal that I shoot will be recovered. I mentally run through different scenarios that could occur while on my stand. I am a good shot and I pride myself on that.

What in the heck happened? I still am running that through my head even after 5 days have passed.

It was the Friday before firearms season. It had rained the night before and was cool and damp when I decided to just sit on the ground in an area we call the “old homestead”. There was an old home there years ago. Now only a fencerow and a strip of woods lead in and out on four sides. A really great looking place to hunt but no trees to put a stand in. Definitely a ground blind hunting area.

After siting on my swivel seat bucket, hunkered in around some brush, a nice eight point buck began to approach from my right. He was checking scrapes and nibbling on some green vegetation that normally grows in the homestead. He was approaching rather cautiously, glancing in my direction as if something really wasn’t right. He saw me but didn’t know what my deal was. He continued on along the fencerow, not more than 20 yards would separate him and myself shortly. I drew my bow back; he took several more steps and was now 20 yards broadside still walking….slowly. I grunted with my mouth, he stopped and stared right at me. It was now or never, so I let the arrow fly….smack. He bolted; tail down, from the way he had came earlier.

I took a deep breath and thought about how it should be a good trailing job and how I had just harvested a nice buck. I sat for around 45 minutes and decided to put a few items back in my truck and trail the buck in an hour or so.

I went to the spot of the shot and could not find any blood. I looked down the fencerow and saw a patch of white (arrow fletching) and knew it was my arrow, broken off around twelve inches in length. A nice pool of blood lied around the arrow and a patch of “white” hair. My heart sunk when I saw the blood trail consisted of small droplets of bright red blood that grew smaller as I followed further.

Well, to make a long story short. After seven hours on my hands and knees, the blood trail ended. The buck had traveled about a quarter mile and stopped bleeding. No obvious tracks or signs of the deer could be located.

I spent the opening morning of firearms season retracing my steps and circling the area where I last found blood to no avail.

It had to have been a shoulder shot. It happened so fast that I did not see where my arrow hit.

I lost a nice deer and I am not proud of it. My next experience with my bow will be spending around 500 or so lung shots on my target deer until it is burnt into my brain.

I’m going back out this year but not until my confidence is back to normal. I gave it my best, but apparently that was not enough.

I was ready, but about four inches to the left of where I should have hit, ended in me not recovering my first bow kill of the season.
 

Passthru

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 16, 2001
Messages
2,364
Reaction score
0
StringShooter,Loosing a deer like that is a hard thing to deal with i know,but you cant let it beat you up,if you let it beat you up you will loose your confidence all together,As bowhunters we do our very best,we practise,we tune our weapons the very best we can,we conceal ourselves the best we can,when its all said and done we are practicly hugging the animal we are hunting,and that animal is so parinoid that its own shadow keeps it on edge. my point here is I dont care how well you prepare,i dont care how good a hunter thinks he is,Every now and then you are going to loose an animal,thats what hunting is and you must be able to accept it and move on.others may disagree but the fact is that sometimes no matter how hard we try to find a wounded animal they do give the slip,it is natures way and things always happen for a reason,that deer may be meant to feed starving scavengers,maybe what you did was just make that buck 100% smarter to allow it to become one of those monster bucks you see in magazines,who knows why,just remember, it just IS.Get back out there and find another deer,it helps to move to a new location so you dont dwell on past events.
 

Tinhorn

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 13, 2001
Messages
3,516
Reaction score
1
Passthru gave a good reply that I believe in too. I did almost the exact same thing several years ago, tracked from 8:30am to 1PM, went out and got help, came back with lanterns near dark and tried to find him till midnight....

went back everyday for 3 days to try to find the deer, listening for crows, etc. I was heart sick over it but don't know what I'd have to do different for a better out come. Sometimes, things happen I guess, but sounds like you went above and beyond what most would have done, including having mental anguish over it

Tinhorn
 

StringShooter

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 23, 2001
Messages
1,098
Reaction score
1
Thanks for the support.

I'm not sitting around letting it get the best of me, but it's just one of those things that if you could just do over again you would have backed the shot further back on the deer.

Nothing I can do about it now, so I will be back out after the firearms season is over.

Learn from your mistakes...

It's just another chapter in the the process of becoming a better hunter.
 

Chairman

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 30, 2001
Messages
431
Reaction score
1
Stringshooter...

If you remember, the same thing happened to me last December. A nice buck (putting it lightly), good shot and..... poor blood trail (one of the reasons I hate having to hunt from the ground). My wife & I searched for over 5 days. Nothing....

I still think about it, when I'm anywhere near that hunting spot. I quit beating myself up, though. We are our own worst critics...

You are a skilled and confident hunter ~ as you should be, after all the practicing you do. Get back out there...
 

Matt in MO

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 26, 2001
Messages
282
Reaction score
0
A buddy of mine had a very similar experience last week with good buck. His brother bagged the buck today with a rifle. It had an obvious shoulder wound but was trailing a doe. They are going to do a 'biopsy" tonight to see what happened to the broadhead.
 

Passthru

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 16, 2001
Messages
2,364
Reaction score
0
Usually the broadhead will grind away at the meat(like hamburger),then a sack will form around the broadhead. that is of course over a long period of time.Slaughter plants will find broadheads all the time during gun season,a guy i know killed a deer one gun season that had 3 different broadheads in it,talk about refusing to die.
 

StringShooter

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 23, 2001
Messages
1,098
Reaction score
1
One of my hunting partners on our property hunted yesterday ( Wednesday 11/20) and after his morning hunt, he decided to walk the area that my bucks blood trail was last seen.

About 200 or so yards down into a creek bottom, lying in some knee high grass, he found the deer.

I had walked this area twice during my two day search but somehow missed spotting the animal. He told me that unless you walked right up to the deer you would have not been able to see him. He also informed me that no blood or other evidence was leading up to where he was lying. He just bedded down and expired, probably right after lying down.

I know that I went beyond what some people would have done in my search but realize that a matter of several feet prevented me from finding him.

He was already in the process of returning to the food chain. The coyotes and other animals had gotten to him. Plus, I shot him last Friday so no meat would be usable.

I am going to return to the location this Saturday, since I am working, and the property is over 100 miles away. I am just planning on removing the skull plate and paying my respects. I also need to roll the deer over to see where arrow actually hit.

I understand that the deer may still have to be tagged. I am in the process of contacting the local agent in my area to see what my alternatives are. Do I use my archery tag? My firearms tag since it is firearms season now? Can I remove the skull plate and leave the deer lay? Does the whole deer, what is left, need to be checked at a check station? Only the agent can give me those answers and I deffinatly want to do everyting the legal way.

I was told that he had four points on his right side and two on his left side.

I will keep everyone informed and at least provide a few pictures of the antlers when I recover them.
 

StringShooter

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 23, 2001
Messages
1,098
Reaction score
1
I talked to the Eastern Office by my home and the lady receptionist said that no agents were in but she said that if I wanted to keep the antlers I would have to tag and check in the deer.

Giving this more thought, I contacted the Northeast Office and actually spoke with an agent. He said due to the timeframe, I could cut off the antlers and leave the animal behind since the meat would not be usuable for consumption. He then gave me the agents name in my county and said to contact him for a possession form. This is the same form that I get when I cut a skull plate from a roadkill deer.

Anyways, I'm going back out Saturday for one more day of firearms hunting and planning on doing some bowhunting on and off before Christmas.

As much as we practice and give our all on a tracking job, sometimes things happen. Passthru is correct, things happen for a reason.

I'm ready again!!!
 

Passthru

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 16, 2001
Messages
2,364
Reaction score
0
Good,Glad your going back out,as i said there is a purpose/reason for everything,Coyotes are tickled to death to eat a meal.At least you know where he is and what happened,and that he is not suffering.
 

SUPER R

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 16, 2002
Messages
68
Reaction score
0
Stringshooter
I shot a deer a while back the evening before rifle season
also. The shot looked good and after 30 min I started
tracking and just knew I'd find the deer (wrong). Looked
till after dark= nothing. The blood trail just stopped in an
open field?
I knew Passthru was stopping by the house on his way
to camp out with his Dad. When he got to my house I
had the lantrens ready. We tracked some more but I never
found the buck. I was sick.
I called the game warden and told him the whole sad
story. I told him I intended on looking for it more in the
morning (opening day of rifle season) and asked him
if I found the deer, could I use my bow tag on it? He told
me I'd have to use my rifle tag. I didn't have a problem
with that. I looked until almost noon= zero.
It's sure is a sick feeling. It happens.
 

Chairman

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 30, 2001
Messages
431
Reaction score
1
Oh what a relief it must of been! I'm glad to hear the good news...

There's nothing like "never knowing"...
<


My neighbor said he just saw the same buck I shot at last year...the one I never found.

All it did was get my mind going 90mph ~ again... The first thing I wanted to say to him was, "I kinda' doubt it...". But, all my neighbors were hunting him last year, too. We call him the Chocolate Buck, because of the coloring of his antlers. I also doubt there's another buck around here the same size, same antler color & characteristics (very unique)....but I hear stranger things have happened.

Here we go again...
<
 

Latest Posts

QRCode

QR Code
Top Bottom